I have had the very unpalatable experience this week
of hearing one of my peers (I am a counsellor and trainer) talk about how they want to build their practice up,
make a living and wondering if working with survivors of childhood sexual abuse
brings in ‘footfall’! It seems to
have come on the back of heightened media coverage of the scale of CSA (Rotherham,
Operation Yewtree, Middlesbrough, Westminster etc.) I am hopeful that for the
most part people reading this will feel equally as horrified as I am but I am
worried that perhaps some might not be.
Working as I do and have done for a number of years
with survivors of childhood abuse, I am often left aghast at how some of my
peers in the counselling profession choose to approach this subject. I have encountered a mixture of fear,
blatant arrogance, smug omnipotence and therapeutic ‘ambulance-chasing’! And it
sickens me. Be under no illusions, this arena is right up at the coal face of
painful human experiences and is not at all for the faint hearted or the
cynical.
Having a compassionate response and a willing heart
is simply not enough. Thinking
that all survivors can be ‘fixed’ is not only naïve but potentially dangerous
for them and for you. Believing
that there is one right answer to fit all is an example of further dehumanizing
of the survivor, short-sighted and dismissive of a person’s phenomenological
experience. To approach this
subject without robust subject knowledge, without resilience in practice,
without the underpinning of an exemplary ethical framework is arrogant,
disempowering and I would even go so far as to say potentially lethal.
I find it galling and frightening that some
counsellors are able to set themselves up after a cursory training or perhaps
because they themselves are survivors and believe that this is sufficient to be
able to offer support to others.
Of course, as Alison Barr (cited below) illustrated in her research a large percentage
of counsellors and therapists get into this game as a direct result of their
own life issues - there is thinking to be done about the Wounded Healer concept. But there has to be a balance between life experience and doing things well. It is a given in addiction services for example that if you had a substance misuse problem in the past then you can bring a lot to working in this field, but you need at least 2 years sobriety and solid personal work before most places will consider your application.
In my opinion, a good therapist worth their salt is continually
checking their ego, continually measuring themselves against an ethical
framework, continually reflecting, both privately and in supervision to check
their motives and agenda for the work that they do, continually seeking CPD and
knowledge about their subject arenas.
For survivors I would say, if you come up against
someone who is not doing any of this, WALK AWAY and hold out for working with
someone who is clear, ethical, who respects and holds out for your personal
agency and empowerment. Someone who is resilient enough not only to work with
you, but robust enough to know when they may have been triggered themselves or
feel out of their depth and refer on in your best interests. Rather than
holding on to you because they are not able to acknowledge that they have hit a
problem in their practice or, more worryingly, because they don’t want to lose
their fee (it happens I am afraid).
If you feel that a counsellor or therapist is more
focused on showing connection with you by sharing their story QUESTION WHY!
What do you get out of it? Does it make you feel sorry for the therapist? Does it make you feel that your abuse
wasn’t as bad or that the therapist is not strong enough to hear your story?
Does it make you feel obligated to them in some way? Do you feel that this means that what worked for them will
work for you? Are you sure that they have worked through their stuff
sufficiently to be be managing their own triggers and well-being? Does it make you angry? What might the counsellor’s motives be?
ASK THEM!
I think the point I am making here for survivors is
be sure that you are comfortable with the person that you are working with and
that you have challenged and asked them about their motives for wanting to work
with you and in what way and that their answers are credible. If in doubt, leave ‘em out!
And to counsellors out there that are dabbling in
this game because they ‘want to help’ or because they see the whole arena of
CSA as a bit of a cash-cow, I think you might benefit from finding somewhere
else to focus your attentions.
Working with CSA is humbling, rewarding when we get
to be a witness to a moment of breakthrough, is tough and scary and exhausting. Working with CSA is a continual
learning experience as every survivor has a unique experience that will need
specific, tailored support – there is no one fix, if only there were! Working
with CSA needs therapists to be continually receptive to new learning and
understanding. We do not assume
that we know everything because we don’t and cant! And above all else, even more so now, all of the work involved with CSA has to be at the highest possible levels of ethics and good practice.
When people ask me why I work in this arena, its in
part because I believe and know that people die because of bad practice and
that I feel it important to be part of the large contingent of practitioners
who want to show that solid, highly ethical and appropriate support is
available for you to help rekindle the potential that was cruelly and wrongly
stolen from you. I am angry about
what happened to survivors in the first place but I am angrier at their further
abuse by cynical, untrained, egotistical therapists who are jumping on a
bandwagon. People deserve better
than that.

No comments:
Post a Comment